Rampart descends into Neptuneโ€™s Grotto

The chubby-cushioned booths are littered with shrugged-off suit jackets and everyone appears to be leaning into the loucheness of it all. Hand me a martini, hand me one for each fist. Iโ€™m in!

Rampart descends into Neptuneโ€™s Grotto
Neptune gazes imperiously at the diners spearing their carne crudi. Grotto Photo: Jason Loucas.

Iโ€™ve always been wary of restaurants or bars that appear to pile on the performance. I feel silly pressing on Trompe-l'oeil bookshelves to reveal secret entrances. Bother me not with passwords; I struggle enough as it is to remember the one for my Amazon account. Even a velvet curtain across a doorway feels like Iโ€™m in a taping of The Muppet Show.

Neptuneโ€™s Grotto is the new mondo Italiano restaurant from the team behind Clam Bar, directly upstairs on Bridge Street in Sydneyโ€™s CBD, and Taylor Swift fave Pellegrino 2000 in Surry Hills. When I step inside Neptuneโ€™s hidden doorway in the shadow of Quay Quarter Tower โ€“ home to the likes of investment bank Barrenjoey, Swedish private equiteers EQT and law firm Corrs โ€“ I have a sinking feeling I might be in this tacky territory. Itโ€™s disarmingly dark โ€“ at lunchtime, in summer! โ€“ and I must totter down a narrow black staircase. Uh oh. Zebra print carpet. Itโ€™s giving off a whiff of Dracula-themed suburban theatre restaurant.